Buying shoes online can feel daunting, especially when shoe sizes can vary widely between different styles and brands. If you're considering trying Tieks ballet flats, we’re here to help you navigate sizing and find your perfect fit. Choosing the right size can make all the difference, helping you fully enjoy Tieks' signature comfort and style.

Read on to learn all about Tieks sizing, whether you're shopping for your first pair in the Tieks Boutiek or encouraging a friend to try the flats with blue bottoms.

Do Tieks Run True to Size?

Tieks flats are available in U.S. women's sizes 5-13 and run true to size for most wearers. If you wear a full size, it's generally best to order Tieks in your regular shoe size.

Since Tieks only come in whole sizes, those who typically wear half sizes often wonder whether to size up or down. Many who wear half sizes can comfortably size up or down. Tieks typically suggests starting with the size down, unless you have a wide foot or sometimes size up. In that case, try sizing up.

No matter your size, be sure to try your Tieks on at home. If they aren't the perfect fit, Tieks has an amazing exchange policy for pairs in their original condition. (Learn more about returns and exchanges below.)

Do Tieks Work For Narrow Or Wide Feet?

One of the standout features of Tieks flat shoes is their flexibility. Crafted with soft, high-quality leather, these flats are designed to stretch and mold to your unique foot. This makes them comfortable for feet of all shapes and sizes, including narrow and wide feet.

For those with narrow feet, heel slipping is a common issue with many ballet flats. Tieks feature cushioned backs that gently hug your heels, keeping the shoes in place and preventing blisters.

If you're researching Tieks for wide feet, keep in mind that the leather will naturally stretch with wear, providing a customized fit. Many Tieks reviews for wide feet note that wearers found comfort and relief after a short break-in period. If you have wide feet and wear a whole size, your regular shoe size should work for you. If you have wide feet and wear a half size, Tieks suggests sizing up for a comfortable fit.

tieks flat shoes in a variety of colorstieks flat shoes in a variety of colors

Material Matters: Leathers, Textiles, & More

The material of your Tieks shoes can make a difference in the sizing and fit. When in doubt, reach out to Tieks customer size or consult the sizing guide on each product page to see what's recommended.

Classic Leather Tieks: Crafted with full-grain and top-grain Italian leathers, Classic Tieks feel soft and supple right out of the box. These styles typically need little to no break-in time, but mold to your feet and get more comfortable with each wear.

Patent Leather Tieks: Patent styles may require a longer break-in period because of their high gloss coating. However, these styles can become just as comfortable as Classic leathers once broken in.

Fabrics & Prints: Certain fabric and print styles, like the Vegan Collection, Mojave, and Aquarella, can have a snugger fit. These styles may require a full size up for the most comfortable fit.

Breaking In Your Tieks

While Tieks are designed for comfort, some wearers may experience a snug fit at first. The soft leather material stretches and molds to the shape of your feet over time, especially where pressure is applied.

Tieks will stretch in the leather upper and elastic area, but they won't stretch in the length. If the length feels too short or long, Tieks' exchange program makes it effortless to try another size to compare. However, if your Tieks feel fine lengthwise, you should have the correct size. Your Tieks may just need a few days to stretch and accommodate the shape of your feet. 

To help break in your Tieks and speed up the natural stretching process, try wearing them around your home for a day or two with thick socks. Just be sure to avoid wearing them outside until you're sure of the fit. You can also try stretching them with wooden stretchers or placing a golf ball or balled up socks in the toe box overnight. This will help to apply consistent pressure and free up some room in that area. 

woman wearing cobalt blue tieks flats with jeanswoman wearing cobalt blue tieks flats with jeans

Tieks Customer Service

If you need assistance with sizing and fit, Tieks customer service is well-known for being responsive and supportive. If you try a pair of Tieks that aren't a perfect fit, they’ll help you with quick, easy exchanges and returns. As long as your Tieks remain in original condition, you can exchange or return anytime within one year of your original order date. Plus, Tieks covers the shipping both ways in the U.S.

Tieks' unique exchange program allows you to compare two different sizes side by side in your home. If you're unsure about your Tieks' fit and want to try a size up or down, submit an exchange request here. Your new size will be shipped to you free of charge. You'll also receive a prepaid return label to send back whatever you decide not to keep.

Step Into Comfort with the Right Fit

When buying your first pair of Tieks, the right size can help you enjoy their comfort and style from the start. With their flexible design, premium materials, and generous exchange policy, Tieks makes it easy to feel confident in your purchase.

Still deciding? Tieks reviews break it down best:

  • “I was so nervous before trying Tieks because I have wide feet and bunions. I wondered, do Tieks stretch? Are Tieks good for wide feet? After just a few wears, they stretched out perfectly so I can say absolutely to both.” – Karen M.
  • "Are Tieks true to size? My regular size 9 works just right for me, so I'd recommend starting with your normal size. You will love them!" - Lauren B.
  • "Don't be worried if you aren't sure which size to order. Tieks has an incredible exchange policy. You just let them know you need a different size and they'll send them out right away, and even the return shipping is free." - Ruth V.